Maybe I’ve overreached concerning the importance of doctrine. Apparently the success of the United States’ military is not because of a well understood core of doctrine but because of our disregard for it:
One of the serious problems in planning the fight against American doctrine, is that the Americans do not read their manuals, nor do they feel any obligation to follow their doctrine.
–From a Soviet Junior Officer’s Notebook
NTM-A is following this doctrinal anarchy to the letter. Some years ago, doctrine was written for the ANSF. Since that time, hoards of Americans, Europeans, and other supporters have flooded the country (6-12 months at a time) and not only disregarded that doctrine but layered their own view of how an Army (or Police) ought to run. Given the disdain the average soldier has for doctrine, their view of how things run is unlikely to be anything similar to anyone else, even if from the same background!
So instead of following any doctrine (good, bad, or indifferent), we train them from the beginning to disregard it and “fight on the fly.” This probably works satisfactorily for the Taliban, Mujahideen, Hakkani Network, and warlords.
Given the precedent for new militaries, the entire U.S. effort will collapse under its own weight without a well established and understood doctrine forming the principles and common language from which all forces can operate (see FM 3.0, Appendix D).